supereo_

guide // versus // 2026

Otterly vs AthenaHQ in 2026

Choose Otterly if you want low-cost tracking and a ranked list of fixes your own team makes; choose AthenaHQ if you want the platform to write content and push it to your CMS as well[1]. That is the line between them: Otterly audits and recommends[4], while AthenaHQ drafts and ships part of the work. supereo is the third option, our pick, and we make it: it does the whole job, on your site and off it, and proves each change against control prompts. On their own pricing pages, Otterly starts at $29 a month, AthenaHQ has a free plan, Essential, then starts at $295 a month and supereo starts at $149 a month. Of the three, supereo is the only one that says it proves each change against control prompts.

Updated . Prices checked between 9 November 2026 and 19 November 2026.

The verdict

  1. The third option: all of the work, proven

    supereoour pick, and we make it

    • best for teams that want AEO done, not a dashboard: supereo does everything it takes to get you recommended, from your site and pages to the roundups, placements and videos AI reads;
    • it proves each move against control prompts, with sample sizes and ranges on every number;
    • run it from Claude or ChatGPT: an MCP server with the same tools supereo's own agent uses.

    From $149 a month

    Run the free auditFree, no card, every answer shown.
  2. Low-cost tracking with ranked fixes

    Otterly

    Best for low-cost monitoring of brand mentions and website citations in AI search. OtterlyAI helps you track brand mentions in AI Search platforms like ChatGPT, Perplexity, Google AI Overviews, and AI Mode. otterly.ai

    From $29 a month

  3. Content drafted and sent to your CMS

    AthenaHQ

    Best for AEO specialists who want one platform for tracking, content and citation work. The complete toolkit for AI Engine Optimization specialists. athenahq.ai

    Free plan, then from $295 a month

Side by side

supereothird option, our pickOtterlyAthenaHQ
Best forAEO done, not a dashboardlow-cost monitoring of brand mentions and website citations in AI searchAEO specialists who want one platform for tracking, content and citation work
Does the workYes–Yes
Proves it against controlsYes––
Runs from Claude or ChatGPTYesYesYes
Free auditYesYesYes
PriceFrom $149 a monthFrom $29 a monthFree plan, then from $295 a month
Prompts at that price4015Unlimited
PlansAutopilotLite, Standard, Premium, EnterpriseEssential, Starter, Enterprise
  • Does the work: it changes the site, writes pages or places the brand itself, beyond tracking, reporting and recommending.
  • Proves it against controls: it measures each change against control prompts, or a held-out group, the change could not move.
  • Runs from Claude or ChatGPT: Claude or ChatGPT can run it over MCP.
  • Free audit: anyone can run an audit with it without paying or starting a trial.
  • Yes means the tool's own page says it, quoted under each tool below; a dash means none of the pages we read says it.

Otterly vs AthenaHQ: the differences

Doing the work: AthenaHQ goes past the report. It sends articles to WordPress, Shopify and other CMSs[1], drafts fixes from its Site Health audits and pushes them to your connected CMS[2], and drafts a pitch to each author of a page that AI answers cite[3]. Otterly audits your site the way AI crawlers see it and hands your team a prioritized list of fixes[4], with content briefs for the pages AI skips[5]. Writing and shipping them stays with you.

Buying: Otterly publishes every plan, from Lite for solo marketers and small teams[6] up to Premium for mid-sized companies and agencies[7], and every one of them takes unlimited brands, competitors, countries and team members[8]. AthenaHQ starts free on its Essential plan[9], then has one self-serve paid plan, Starter[10], with Enterprise at custom pricing[11]. The side by side has both ladders, read from each pricing page.

Credits and engines: both bill by the answer. On Otterly one credit is one prompt checked once on one engine[12], any plan can track any of its engines[13], and a Claude answer costs three credits rather than one[14]. AthenaHQ's free plan reads ChatGPT, Perplexity, Gemini, AI Overviews and Copilot, and its paid plans add Google AI Mode, Claude, Grok, DeepSeek and Meta AI[16], where an answer from one of the heavier models costs 5 credits[17].

Claude itself: Otterly reads Claude through its API, with the Haiku model and web search[15]. If your buyers ask Claude for recommendations, check that this is the answer you want measured before you spend credits on it.

Who each one suits

Otterly suits in-house marketing teams tracking their brand in AI answers, agencies that need repeatable reports for many clients, and SEO and GEO practitioners who want measurable signals[18], above all on a small budget. It also lists the sites and directories AI engines already cite for your prompts, where you can book a placement inside the platform[19].

AthenaHQ suits teams that want the tool to produce work, not only reports: it names self-guided small businesses for its free and Starter plans, and enterprises and agencies for Enterprise[20]. Its deepest tools, the Knowledge Base claim review, Oracle discrepancy detection and its Citation Engine, are Enterprise features[21], so a small team on Starter gets the content tools without them.

Who stands behind each, and what a security review will ask

AthenaHQ is now part of Bloomreach[22]. It says accounts, contracts and support stay exactly as they are[23], and that the first launches that bring the two together come in early 2027[24]. If you're signing for a year, ask what that roadmap changes for your plan.

Otterly is a remote company headquartered in Austria[25], and its first product, a monitoring tool for AI search, launched in October 2024[26]. For a security review the two differ plainly: AthenaHQ holds SOC 2 Type 2 certification[28], while Otterly's SOC 2 Type II audit is on its roadmap with no date set[27].

Running each from Claude or ChatGPT

Both have MCP servers that can change things as well as read them. Otterly's answers plain-language questions about your reports, prompts, citations and audits[29], and with write permission it creates and deletes prompts and tags[30]. AthenaHQ's goes further into the work: you can create content, revise briefs, manage prompts and update brand facts from your assistant[31].

Mind the plan you buy. Otterly's cheapest plan includes no API or MCP access[32], and on AthenaHQ's Starter the API is an add-on billed on top[33].

The third option: supereo

Otterly tells your team what to fix and AthenaHQ drafts part of it[4][2]. supereo does the whole job: it changes your site, writes the pages AI is missing, and works off your site on the roundups, placements and videos AI reads, then measures each change against control prompts it couldn't move, with sample sizes and ranges on every number. Neither page above says it proves its changes that way; the side by side shows what each one claims.

The next step costs nothing: run the free audit on your own site, with no card, and see every AI answer as it comes in. Then compare each head to head in supereo vs Otterly and supereo vs AthenaHQ, read the Otterly review and the AthenaHQ review, or see every Otterly alternative and AthenaHQ alternative.

The tools

01supereoour pick, and we make it

  • best for teams that want AEO done, not a dashboard: supereo does everything it takes to get you recommended, from your site and pages to the roundups, placements and videos AI reads;
  • it proves each move against control prompts, with sample sizes and ranges on every number;
  • run it from Claude or ChatGPT: an MCP server with the same tools supereo's own agent uses.

From $149 a month

  • Does the worksupereo writes those pages for you, aimed at the questions where AI skips you. supereo.app
  • Proves it against controlsEach change has a few target questions, and we compare them with your other questions, the ones no change targets. supereo.app
  • Runs from Claude or ChatGPTRun the same loop from Claude, Cursor or Codex. Your agent gets every tool supereo's own agent uses: your buyers' questions, every answer, the pages AI cites, your brand facts. supereo.app
  • Free auditfree audit // about 2 minutes // no card supereo.app
PlanA monthPromptsAI engines
Autopilot$14940ChatGPT, Google AI Overviews, Google AI Mode, Gemini, Perplexity, Claude

Prices from supereo.app, checked 19 November 2026. What it does, from its own pages, checked 16 November 2026.

How the proof works, with every number it runs on: How supereo measures.

02AthenaHQ

Best for AEO specialists who want one platform for tracking, content and citation work. In its own words: The complete toolkit for AI Engine Optimization specialists. athenahq.ai

Free plan, then from $295 a month

  • Does the workShopify lets you publish AEO-optimized content and attribute revenue to AI Search. athenahq.ai
  • Proves it against controlsNone of its pages we read says so.
  • Runs from Claude or ChatGPTAthenaHQ ships a remote Model Context Protocol (MCP) server. Once connected, an AI assistant like Claude or ChatGPT can query your AI search visibility data in plain language docs.athenahq.ai
  • Free auditGet Free Audit (10m) athenahq.ai
PlanA monthPromptsAI engines
EssentialFree–ChatGPT, Google AI Overviews, Gemini, Perplexity, Microsoft Copilot
Starter$295UnlimitedChatGPT, Google AI Overviews, Google AI Mode, Gemini, Perplexity, Claude, Microsoft Copilot, Grok, DeepSeek, Meta AI, Mistral
EnterpriseCustom–ChatGPT, Google AI Overviews, Google AI Mode, Gemini, Perplexity, Claude, Microsoft Copilot, Grok

Prices from athenahq.ai, checked 16 November 2026. What it does, from its own pages, checked 16 November 2026.

03Otterly

Best for low-cost monitoring of brand mentions and website citations in AI search. In its own words: OtterlyAI helps you track brand mentions in AI Search platforms like ChatGPT, Perplexity, Google AI Overviews, and AI Mode. otterly.ai

From $29 a month

  • Does the workNone of its pages we read says so.
  • Proves it against controlsNone of its pages we read says so.
  • Runs from Claude or ChatGPTConnect OtterlyAI to Claude, ChatGPT, Cursor, and any MCP-compatible client. otterly.ai
  • Free auditCheck any URL for AI-search readiness. Get a structured GEO score and actionable optimization tips. otterly.ai
PlanA monthPromptsAI engines
Lite$2915ChatGPT, Google AI Overviews, Perplexity, Microsoft Copilot
Standard$189100ChatGPT, Google AI Overviews, Perplexity, Microsoft Copilot
Premium$489400ChatGPT, Google AI Overviews, Perplexity, Microsoft Copilot
EnterpriseCustomUnlimitedChatGPT, Google AI Overviews, Google AI Mode, Gemini, Perplexity, Claude, Microsoft Copilot

Prices from otterly.ai, checked 16 November 2026. What it does, from its own pages, checked 16 November 2026.

Questions

Should I choose Otterly or AthenaHQ?

Otterly if you want low-cost tracking and a ranked list of fixes for your team to make; AthenaHQ if you want a platform that also writes content and sends it to your CMS[1]. For the whole job done and measured, supereo is the third option, and our pick.

Is Otterly cheaper than AthenaHQ?

To start paying, yes: Otterly's Lite plan is $29 a month[6] and AthenaHQ's Starter $295 a month[10]. AthenaHQ has a free plan as well[9], and both bill usage in credits, so price the prompts and engines you need; every plan is in the side by side.

Which one tracks Claude?

Both. Otterly can track it on any plan, through Claude's API with the Haiku model, and a Claude answer costs three credits[15][14]. AthenaHQ adds Claude on its paid plans[16], at 5 credits an answer[17].

Can I try Otterly or AthenaHQ for free?

Yes. Otterly has a 7-day free trial with no credit card[34] and free GEO tools that score any URL[35]. AthenaHQ has a free plan[9] and a free audit it emails you within the hour[36]. supereo's audit is free too, with no card, and shows every AI answer it gets: try it on your site.

Which is better for an agency?

Both court agencies. Otterly includes pitch workspaces for prospects and branded reports through Google Looker Studio[37]; AthenaHQ offers discounted licenses so an agency can sell AthenaHQ with its own services for the price a brand would pay alone[38].

Does Otterly write content like AthenaHQ does?

No: Otterly drafts content briefs and ranks fixes[5][4], and your team writes and publishes. AthenaHQ sends articles and page fixes to your CMS[1][2]. supereo writes and ships the changes, and proves what each one did.

How we compiled this

Every price, prompt cap and AI engine on this page comes from each tool's own pricing page, and every capability from the tool's own product pages, docs and free tools. supereo reads them every week and keeps a value only when the page states it word for word; each tool on this page names the page and the day it was last checked.

Prices are US dollars a month on monthly billing, or the monthly price of an annual plan where that is the only price the page states, marked billed annually. A free trial is not a free plan, and custom pricing is a price the page does not publish. A tool sold only as part of a bigger product says so beside its prices.

Yes means the tool's own page says it, in the words quoted under each tool. A dash means none of the pages we read says it, so the tool may still do it without saying so there.

We make supereo, so it is listed first, as our pick. The other tools follow by how many of the four jobs their own pages claim, then by price.

Where this page's words state something the dataset doesn't hold, such as a change a tool made, the sentence links its source and the day it was read.

How supereo measures its own results, with every number it runs on: How supereo measures.

supereo (supereo.app) is an AI agent that does everything it takes to get your brand recommended by ChatGPT, Gemini, Perplexity, Claude and Google, on your site and off it: site fixes, new pages, roundups, placements and video. It proves what worked against control prompts. Made by superagnt.

Sources

  1. Publish without leaving AthenaHQ. Send articles to WordPress, Shopify, and other CMSs. athenahq.ai, read 18 November 2026.
  2. When Site Health audits find opportunities to improve your SEO, Athena can draft fixes. This board is where you manage those drafts, push them to your connected CMS (or export them for manual entry), and track whether the changes have successfully gone live. docs.athenahq.ai, read 18 November 2026.
  3. Outreach finds the authors of pages that AI answers cite and drafts a pitch to each. docs.athenahq.ai, read 18 November 2026.
  4. OtterlyAI audits your site the way AI crawlers see it, then hands your team a prioritized list of fixes. otterly.ai, read 18 November 2026.
  5. Know why AI skips your content — and fix it. Crawlability checks, Content Audit & Prediction, and Content Briefs that turn invisible pages into AI sources. otterly.ai, read 18 November 2026.
  6. Lite $29 /month Save $52 For solo marketers and small teams Prompts 20 prompts = 2,000 credits/month 3 of 7 AI engines Daily otterly.ai, read 18 November 2026.
  7. Premium $489 /month Save $880 For mid-sized companies and agencies Prompts 535 prompts = 50,000 credits/month otterly.ai, read 18 November 2026.
  8. Analyze and optimize for AI Search. Unlimited brands, competitors, countries, and team members on every plan. otterly.ai, read 18 November 2026.
  9. Essential Free $25 free credit Includes 300 credits ChatGPT perplexity AI Overviews gemini copilot Unlimited users Prompt and response analysis Sources and competitor insights Content recommendations Athena AI agent athenahq.ai, read 18 November 2026.
  10. Starter $ 295 /month $300/month free credit 3,600 credits athenahq.ai, read 18 November 2026.
  11. Enterprise Custom Custom credits 1 credit = 1 AI response athenahq.ai, read 18 November 2026.
  12. One credit is one prompt checked once on one AI engine. A prompt tracked daily on 1 engine uses 31 credits per month. otterly.ai, read 18 November 2026.
  13. Every plan can track every engine. Each engine uses credits. otterly.ai, read 18 November 2026.
  14. Analyzing Claude is 3x more expensive for us, therefore each Claude answer counts as 3 credits. All other engines count as 1. otterly.ai, read 18 November 2026.
  15. Claude - we track Claude via API, using Haiku model with web search capabilities. help.otterly.ai, read 18 November 2026.
  16. All plans include ChatGPT, Perplexity, Gemini, Google AI Overviews, and Copilot. Paid plans add Google AI Mode, Claude, Grok, DeepSeek, and Meta AI. athenahq.ai, read 18 November 2026.
  17. Grok responses are now billed at 5 credits each, like Claude, DeepSeek, Meta AI and Mistral. docs.athenahq.ai, read 18 November 2026.
  18. In-house marketing teams tracking how their brand appears in AI answers Agencies that need repeatable AI visibility reporting for multiple clients SEO / GEO / AEO practitioners who want measurable signals and workflows for AI search visibility otterly.ai, read 18 November 2026.
  19. Browse vetted sites, directories and publishers that AI engines already cite for your prompts, and book a placement without ever leaving the platform. otterly.ai, read 18 November 2026.
  20. Best for Self-Guided SMBs Enterprises & Agencies athenahq.ai, read 18 November 2026.
  21. Knowledge Base and claim review Oracle discrepancy detection Athena Citation Engine (ACE) New feature SAML and OIDC SSO athenahq.ai, read 18 November 2026.
  22. AthenaHQ is now part of Bloomreach athenahq.ai, read 18 November 2026.
  23. Your AthenaHQ account, contracts, and support stay exactly as they are, and you will keep working with the same team you know. athenahq.ai, read 18 November 2026.
  24. We are already working on new use cases that bring AthenaHQ and Bloomreach together. The first launches in early 2027. athenahq.ai, read 18 November 2026.
  25. OtterlyAI is a fully remote company headquartered in Austria, with a team across Europe. otterly.ai, read 18 November 2026.
  26. OtterlyAI initial product - as an AI Search Monitoring tool - launched in October 2024. otterly.ai, read 18 November 2026.
  27. Our SOC-2 Type II audit is an item on our roadmap but no date has been set. help.otterly.ai, read 18 November 2026.
  28. We hold SOC II Type 2 certification, are fully GDPR compliant for EU and UK data processing, and have implemented the NIST Cybersecurity Framework at Tier 3 under CSF 2.0. athenahq.ai, read 18 November 2026.
  29. Connect OtterlyAI to Claude, ChatGPT, Cursor, and any MCP-compatible client. Ask plain-language questions about your brand reports, prompts, citations, recommendations, and GEO audits - answered straight from your live data. otterly.ai, read 18 November 2026.
  30. Create and delete prompts, and create and delete tags — manage your prompt set and tags directly from your AI assistant (requires write permission) help.otterly.ai, read 18 November 2026.
  31. You can also create content, revise briefs, manage prompts, and update brand facts. Your account permissions determine which tools you can use. athenahq.ai, read 18 November 2026.
  32. Included Group onboarding session Not included API & MCP access Not included Agent analytics Not included Data Studio connector otterly.ai, read 18 November 2026.
  33. API access is available on Starter as an add-on billed on top of the subscription. athenahq.ai, read 18 November 2026.
  34. Yes, OtterlyAI provides a 7-day free trial for new users. This allows you to explore our platform and its features without any commitment. No credit card needed. otterly.ai, read 18 November 2026.
  35. Check any URL for AI-search readiness. Get a structured GEO score and actionable optimization tips. otterly.ai, read 18 November 2026.
  36. We're Sourcing Your Custom Audit You should receive it by email within an hour. athenahq.ai, read 18 November 2026.
  37. Pitch Workspaces: Run custom audits for prospects before they sign Included Your own reporting: Custom reports via Google Looker Studio with your branding otterly.ai, read 18 November 2026.
  38. Unlock discounted AthenaHQ licenses that let you offer AthenaHQ + your agency's managed services, all for the same price a brand would typically pay for AthenaHQ alone. athenahq.ai, read 18 November 2026.

install with one prompt // any AI agent

Install supereo with one prompt.

Paste one line into the agent you already use. Coding agents set supereo up themselves, and Claude and ChatGPT walk you through adding it. You sign in once, then ask it how AI sees your site.

setup prompt

Install supereo for me. It's the supereo MCP server at https://mcp.supereo.app/mcp (on Claude it's a connector I add in my browser; elsewhere I sign in through my browser). The setup guide for each kind of agent is at https://supereo.app/install
  1. 01copy the prompt
  2. 02paste it into your agent
  3. 03sign in once, in your browser

or wire it by hand

https://mcp.supereo.app/mcp
claude · ~/dev/acme
Claude Code v2.1.206

Welcome back Alex!

Opus 5.5 · Claude Max · ~/dev/acme

⏸ manual mode on · ? for shortcuts

An example session. The same prompt works in every client.