guide // versus // 2026
Otterly vs Semrush in 2026
Choose Semrush's AI Visibility Toolkit if your team already works in Semrush and wants AI visibility beside its SEO data: Semrush One puts both toolkits in a single subscription[1]. Choose Otterly if many people or brands need covering, since every Otterly plan takes unlimited team members and brands[2]. That is what decides most cases: Semrush sells the toolkit per user, another $99 license for each subuser[3], so its cost climbs with headcount, while Otterly's plans step up by prompts and credits instead[4]. supereo is our pick, and we make it: a third option that doesn't stop at tracking, but does the work on your site and off it and proves each change against control prompts. On their own pricing pages, Otterly starts at $29 a month, Semrush AI Visibility Toolkit starts at $99 a month, billed annually and supereo starts at $149 a month. Of the three, supereo is the only one that says it proves each change against control prompts.
Updated . Prices checked between 9 November 2026 and 19 November 2026.
The verdict
Third option: it makes the changes, then proves them
supereoour pick, and we make it
- best for teams that want AEO done, not a dashboard: supereo does everything it takes to get you recommended, from your site and pages to the roundups, placements and videos AI reads;
- it proves each move against control prompts, with sample sizes and ranges on every number;
- run it from Claude or ChatGPT: an MCP server with the same tools supereo's own agent uses.
From $149 a month
Run the free auditFree, no card, every answer shown.Every seat and brand on one plan
Best for low-cost monitoring of brand mentions and website citations in AI search.
OtterlyAI helps you track brand mentions in AI Search platforms like ChatGPT, Perplexity, Google AI Overviews, and AI Mode.
otterly.aiFrom $29 a month
AI visibility inside the Semrush suite
Best for SEOs and marketers already on Semrush who want AI visibility beside their SEO data.
This toolkit is designed for SEOs and marketers who want to monitor how their site and competitors are positioned across AI systems.
semrush.comFrom $99 a month, billed annually
Side by side
| supereothird option, our pick | Otterly | Semrush AI Visibility Toolkit | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Best for | AEO done, not a dashboard | low-cost monitoring of brand mentions and website citations in AI search | SEOs and marketers already on Semrush who want AI visibility beside their SEO data |
| Does the work | Yes | – | – |
| Proves it against controls | Yes | – | – |
| Runs from Claude or ChatGPT | Yes | Yes | – |
| Free audit | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| Price | From $149 a month | From $29 a month | From $99 a month, billed annually |
| Prompts at that price | 40 | 15 | 25 |
| Plans | Autopilot | Lite, Standard, Premium, Enterprise | Base, Semrush for Enterprise |
- Does the work: it changes the site, writes pages or places the brand itself, beyond tracking, reporting and recommending.
- Proves it against controls: it measures each change against control prompts, or a held-out group, the change could not move.
- Runs from Claude or ChatGPT: Claude or ChatGPT can run it over MCP.
- Free audit: anyone can run an audit with it without paying or starting a trial.
- Yes means the tool's own page says it, quoted under each tool below; a dash means none of the pages we read says it.
Otterly vs Semrush: the differences
Seats and brands: the toolkit is licensed person by person, another $99 for each subuser on a corporate account[3]. Otterly puts no cap on team members, brands, competitors or countries, whichever plan you buy[2].
Prompts: the toolkit alone includes one domain and 25 prompts for Prompt Tracking[5], and 50 more cost $60 a month[6]. Otterly sizes its plans in prompts and credits, with 160 prompts on Standard[4]. The side by side lists what each price buys.
Engines: Semrush lists ChatGPT, Gemini, Perplexity, SearchGPT, Google AI Mode and Google AI Overviews, with Enterprise AIO adding depth and coverage, and Claude isn't among the names[7]. Otterly's home page names seven engines, Claude and Copilot included[8].
Research: Semrush's AI Analysis reports draw on a database of over 317 million prompts and responses[9], a market-wide view you won't build from your own prompts. Otterly works outward from yours: its Gap Analyzer surfaces the prompts where competitors get named and you don't[10].
Already paying for Semrush?
Then you have three routes. Semrush One folds the AI Visibility Toolkit into the same subscription as the SEO toolkit[1]. Otterly sells an app in the Semrush App Center, which its own help center calls a reduced feature set next to the full platform[11]. Or you run Otterly on its own, beside Semrush, and keep both logins.
Check the MCP before you count on it. Semrush's needs a Semrush One, SEO Classic or Trends API subscription[12] and serves Semrush's SEO, traffic and competitive data[13]; none of the Semrush pages we read lists the AI visibility reports among what it serves.
Who should buy which
Semrush's toolkit is designed for monitoring one or a few domains[19], so it suits an SEO team that already works in Semrush, has few brands and wants AI answers read next to its rankings. Its recommendations target how your brand is positioned in those answers[20].
Otterly suits an agency with many clients, or a team that hands a login to everyone, because neither changes the price[2]. It also suits buyers who ask Claude or Copilot, which Otterly covers[8].
The third option: supereo
On the pages we read, neither Semrush's toolkit nor Otterly says it makes the changes itself; the side by side marks that for each. supereo is built around making them. It rewrites what holds your pages back, publishes the comparison, alternatives and answer pages AI is missing, and goes after the roundups, videos and placements off your site, then confirms each change went live. When it can't ship to your stack, your team receives the exact text.
It also shows what each change did. A change aims at 1 to 5 target prompts and is read against control prompts it couldn't have moved, with a sample size and a range on every number, ending as worked, no change, made it worse or too close to call: see how supereo measures. It asks the same six engines for every brand, three times a week, Claude included, sells none as an add-on, and its MCP server carries the tools its own agent uses.
To start, run the free audit: a site and a work email, no card, every answer visible. For one rival at a time, see supereo vs Otterly or supereo vs Semrush; for more depth, the Otterly review, the Semrush AI Visibility Toolkit review, Otterly alternatives and Semrush alternatives.
The tools
01supereoour pick, and we make it
- best for teams that want AEO done, not a dashboard: supereo does everything it takes to get you recommended, from your site and pages to the roundups, placements and videos AI reads;
- it proves each move against control prompts, with sample sizes and ranges on every number;
- run it from Claude or ChatGPT: an MCP server with the same tools supereo's own agent uses.
From $149 a month
- Does the work
supereo writes those pages for you, aimed at the questions where AI skips you.
supereo.app - Proves it against controls
Each change has a few target questions, and we compare them with your other questions, the ones no change targets.
supereo.app - Runs from Claude or ChatGPT
Run the same loop from Claude, Cursor or Codex. Your agent gets every tool supereo's own agent uses: your buyers' questions, every answer, the pages AI cites, your brand facts.
supereo.app - Free audit
free audit // about 2 minutes // no card
supereo.app
| Plan | A month | Prompts | AI engines |
|---|---|---|---|
| Autopilot | $149 | 40 | ChatGPT, Google AI Overviews, Google AI Mode, Gemini, Perplexity, Claude |
Prices from supereo.app, checked 19 November 2026. What it does, from its own pages, checked 16 November 2026.
How the proof works, with every number it runs on: How supereo measures.
02Otterly
Best for low-cost monitoring of brand mentions and website citations in AI search. In its own words: OtterlyAI helps you track brand mentions in AI Search platforms like ChatGPT, Perplexity, Google AI Overviews, and AI Mode.
otterly.ai
From $29 a month
- Does the workNone of its pages we read says so.
- Proves it against controlsNone of its pages we read says so.
- Runs from Claude or ChatGPT
Connect OtterlyAI to Claude, ChatGPT, Cursor, and any MCP-compatible client.
otterly.ai - Free audit
Check any URL for AI-search readiness. Get a structured GEO score and actionable optimization tips.
otterly.ai
| Plan | A month | Prompts | AI engines |
|---|---|---|---|
| Lite | $29 | 15 | ChatGPT, Google AI Overviews, Perplexity, Microsoft Copilot |
| Standard | $189 | 100 | ChatGPT, Google AI Overviews, Perplexity, Microsoft Copilot |
| Premium | $489 | 400 | ChatGPT, Google AI Overviews, Perplexity, Microsoft Copilot |
| Enterprise | Custom | Unlimited | ChatGPT, Google AI Overviews, Google AI Mode, Gemini, Perplexity, Claude, Microsoft Copilot |
Prices from otterly.ai, checked 16 November 2026. What it does, from its own pages, checked 16 November 2026.
03Semrush AI Visibility Toolkit
Best for SEOs and marketers already on Semrush who want AI visibility beside their SEO data. In its own words: This toolkit is designed for SEOs and marketers who want to monitor how their site and competitors are positioned across AI systems.
semrush.com
From $99 a month, billed annually
- Does the workNone of its pages we read says so.
- Proves it against controlsNone of its pages we read says so.
- Runs from Claude or ChatGPTNone of its pages we read says so.
- Free audit
Yes, the AI Visibility Checker is free to use. You can use the tool three times per day for free, without registering or creating an account.
semrush.com
| Plan | A month | Prompts | AI engines |
|---|---|---|---|
| Base | $99 billed annually | 25 | ChatGPT, Gemini, Perplexity, Google AI |
| Semrush for Enterprise | Custom | – | – |
Prices from semrush.com, checked 16 November 2026. What it does, from its own pages, checked 16 November 2026.
Questions
Should I choose Otterly or Semrush?
Semrush's toolkit if your team lives in Semrush and wants AI data next to its SEO data[1]; Otterly if you need many seats, brands or engines, since no Otterly plan caps team members or brands[2]. If you want the work itself done and proven against control prompts, supereo is our pick, and we make it.
Is Semrush's AI Visibility Toolkit cheaper than Otterly?
Not to start: the toolkit is $99 a month per domain, billed annually[18], and Otterly's Lite plan is $29 a month[17]. The gap grows with the team, since each Semrush subuser needs another $99 license[3] while Otterly charges nothing per team member[2]. Every plan of both is in the side by side.
Does Semrush track Claude?
Its own list of the models it tracks doesn't name Claude: ChatGPT, Gemini, Perplexity, SearchGPT, Google AI Mode and Google AI Overviews, with Enterprise AIO adding coverage[7]. Otterly names Claude among its seven engines[8], and supereo asks Claude for every brand as one of its six engines.
Can I try Semrush's toolkit before paying?
Not as a trial: the toolkit offers none[14], though its AI Visibility Checker is free three times a day with no account[15]. Otterly's trial runs 7 days with 7,440 credits[16]. supereo starts with a free audit and no card: check your own site.
Does Otterly work inside Semrush?
Yes, as an app in the Semrush App Center, with a reduced feature set compared with the full Otterly platform[11]. Buy Otterly's own plan if you need everything it does.
How we compiled this
Every price, prompt cap and AI engine on this page comes from each tool's own pricing page, and every capability from the tool's own product pages, docs and free tools. supereo reads them every week and keeps a value only when the page states it word for word; each tool on this page names the page and the day it was last checked.
Prices are US dollars a month on monthly billing, or the monthly price of an annual plan where that is the only price the page states, marked billed annually. A free trial is not a free plan, and custom pricing is a price the page does not publish. A tool sold only as part of a bigger product says so beside its prices.
Yes means the tool's own page says it, in the words quoted under each tool. A dash means none of the pages we read says it, so the tool may still do it without saying so there.
We make supereo, so it is listed first, as our pick. The other tools follow by how many of the four jobs their own pages claim, then by price.
Where this page's words state something the dataset doesn't hold, such as a change a tool made, the sentence links its source and the day it was read.
How supereo measures its own results, with every number it runs on: How supereo measures.
supereo (supereo.app) is an AI agent that does everything it takes to get your brand recommended by ChatGPT, Gemini, Perplexity, Claude and Google, on your site and off it: site fixes, new pages, roundups, placements and video. It proves what worked against control prompts. Made by superagnt.
Sources
Semrush One combines the SEO and AI Visibility toolkits in a single subscription, covering visibility on both search engines and AI chat platforms.
semrush.com, read 18 November 2026.Analyze and optimize for AI Search. Unlimited brands, competitors, countries, and team members on every plan.
otterly.ai, read 18 November 2026.In a corporate account with multiple users, access to the AI Visibility Toolkit can be shared across your team by adding another license ($99) for each subuser on the account.
semrush.com, read 18 November 2026.Standard $189 /month Save $340 For SMEs and marketing teams Prompts 160 prompts = 15,000 credits/month
otterly.ai, read 18 November 2026.Includes: 1 project 1 domain for Brand Performance analysis 300 daily queries in AI Analysis reports and 1000 daily queries in Prompt Research 25 prompts for Prompt Tracking
semrush.com, read 18 November 2026.Additional Prompts: You can add 50 more prompts to your Prompt Tracking limit for $60 per month.
semrush.com, read 18 November 2026.What LLMs does Semrush track? ChatGPT, Gemini, Perplexity, SearchGPT, Google AI Mode, and Google AI Overviews. Enterprise AIO adds additional depth and coverage for multi-market programs.
semrush.com, read 18 November 2026.Your brand, otterly visible on every AI Search Get your brand mentioned and your website cited on ChatGPT, AI Overviews, AI Mode, Gemini, Claude, Perplexity and Copilot.
otterly.ai, read 18 November 2026.These AI Analysis reports are powered by Semrush’s AI prompt database —a collection of over 317 million prompts and responses on ChatGPT, Gemini, Google AI Overviews, and AI Mode.
semrush.com, read 18 November 2026.Surface the prompts where competitors get named and you don't, ranked by how often they come up, so you know which gaps to close first.
otterly.ai, read 18 November 2026.Yes, OtterlyAI is available as an app in the Semrush App Center, but it’s important to know that this version is a reduced feature set compared to the full OtterlyAI platform.
help.otterly.ai, read 18 November 2026.You'll need an active Semrush One, SEO Classic, or Trends API subscription to use Semrush MCP. Depending on your plan, you'll have a minimum of 50,000 MCP API units included, which reset every monthly billing cycle.
semrush.com, read 18 November 2026.Semrush MCP provides access to Semrush's SEO, traffic, and competitive data through your AI assistants.
semrush.com, read 18 November 2026.Price: $99 per month. Trial: No, the AI Visibility Toolkit does not offer a free trial.
semrush.com, read 18 November 2026.Yes, the AI Visibility Checker is free to use. You can use the tool three times per day for free, without registering or creating an account.
semrush.com, read 18 November 2026.Trial length 7 days Credits 7,440 Prompts 60 on 4 engines, or 80 on 3 engines (daily) AI engines Choose at least 3 in onboarding. GEO audits No limit API and MCP calls 1,000 each
help.otterly.ai, read 18 November 2026.Lite $29 /month Save $52 For solo marketers and small teams Prompts 20 prompts = 2,000 credits/month 3 of 7 AI engines Daily
otterly.ai, read 18 November 2026.Base For businesses that want to track how they’re mentioned in AI search $99/mo per domain billed annually Subscribe What’s inside: AI visibility reports for any domain Track 25 custom prompts (daily AI rankings)
semrush.com, read 18 November 2026.The AI Visibility Toolkit is designed for monitoring one or a few domains.
semrush.com, read 18 November 2026.The toolkit then analyzes the AI responses to see how your brand is mentioned, assesses the tone and attributes used, and generates actionable recommendations to refine your brand's positioning.
semrush.com, read 18 November 2026.